An Immigration Solution that Benefits America and Dreamers

Indulge me by pondering a serious question that is routinely asked by concerned citizens as it relates to illegal immigration past and present. Other than massive amounts of drug running, human-trafficking, disease, terrorism, and burdensome new welfare recipients, what are the benefits of open borders? As both a Retired Army Officer and Second Generation Italian-American, I contend there is little benefit for open borders. Contrary to proponents that favor an extension of the freedom of migration between countries there are valid reasons why such freedom of migration is indefensible. Primarily, such restrictions are generally based on public health, order, or safety justifications and suggest that the right to these conditions preempts the notion of freedom of movement.  

My position on immigration is characterized by shades of meaning. I am adamantly opposed to illegal immigration and rewarding benefits to those who have broken the law to enter the United States. At the same time, I am compassionate and fair minded. Citizenship in America is not a song and dance entitlement awarded to anyone and everyone who crosses our borders but, in its place, a special right to be conferred. 

For those who currently fall under the category of Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA), I propose a not so novel idea, that is likely shared by others. Why not have Congress pass legislation that expedites citizenship for DACA immigrants who serve in the U.S. Uniformed Military Services. In the case of those emigres who were brought here as children who fail to meet the entry standards for military recruitment an alternative would be community or designated federal services much the same as Franklin D. Roosevelt’s New Deal Program. 

Simply put, would not the suggestion of required military or community service deliver fairness to a group that merits it? From what I understand the military branches are struggling to meet, and in some cases falling short of, their recruiting goals. What better incentive for a young law-abiding Dreamer to join the military than to be rewarded with an honor that is truly earned? In the case of community service, what community does not have wants or requirements to make it a better place to live? 

Instead of asking for in-state college tuition rates, these immigrants can serve our nation and then use the GI Bill benefits they have earned. Few people wish to reward illegal behavior. This is an opportunity to pay back the United States for the honor of becoming an American citizen. I am of the opinion if someone loves America enough to potentially risk his or her life defending it, there’s more than a good chance that individual will be an asset to their nation and community.

The steps mentioned should not be viewed as a weakening of immigration reform but rather righting a wrong that has simmered long enough. This writer favors border security that includes physical barriers, immigration reform, increase in border patrol manpower, and if necessary, federalization of National Guard troops to assist in border security operations. I, unlike some Congressional ideologues have a firm stance against using taxpayers’ monies to fund sanctuary cities/states that refuse to cooperate with Immigration and Custom Enforcement (ICE) personnel. Unlike some politicians who appallingly call for abolishing ICE and are in favor of open borders, we should recognize the essential contributions of Border Patrol and Ice agents make to America’s national security.

In summation, America needs substantive border control measures to insure the safety and wellbeing of its citizens. Fast tracking DACA immigrants for citizenship by either serving in United Sates Armed Forces or programs that directly benefit a community or its institutions is beneficial to both Dreamers and America. The personal benefits are real for a variety of reasons, including citizenship requirements and requisites of certain benefits to be determined by Congressional legislation. The time has come for the Executive and  Legislative branches of government to broker a viable immigration reform law that halts illegal entry and addresses this nation's Dreamers dilemma.